BAAO · Astro Challenge · Sections A–C

Galaxies and Cosmology

9 questions — reveal the final answers. Full worked solutions: the book.

2018 Q122018Section B · Short answerGalaxies and Cosmology · Cosmic microwave background and redshift
Cosmic Microwave Background

The cosmic microwave background (CMB) is measured today to have an almost perfectly uniform temperature of $T_0 = 2.725$ K. The temperature of the CMB at any redshift can be calculated using $T = T_0(1+z)$ where $z$ is the redshift. During the early expansion of the Universe, the temperature was high enough to ionize the hydrogen atoms filling the universe and make the universe opaque. Once the temperature dropped below 3000 K the universe became transparent and the CMB was emitted in a process known as photon decoupling.

figure
Figure 2: Left: The CMB has been measured to have an almost perfect black-body spectrum. Credit: NASA/WMAP Science Team. Right: The Planck satellite was launched to measure the tiny deviations from a perfect black-body. This is the map of the sky from their final data release from July 2018. Credit: ESA/Planck Collaboration.

The relative size of the Universe, called the scale factor $a$, varies with redshift as $a = a_0(1+z)^{-1}$, whilst in a matter dominated universe (a valid assumption after the CMB was emitted) the scale factor varies with time $t$ as $a \propto t^{2/3}$.

(a) If the scale factor today is defined to be $a_0 \equiv 1$, calculate the age of the Universe when the CMB was emitted. [Current age of the Universe $t_0 = 13.8$ Gyr.]

(b) What was the temperature of the CMB when the Earth formed 4.5 Gyr ago?

Show answer · 显示答案
Final answers · 最终答案
  • (a)$t_\text{dec} \approx 380\,000\,\text{yr}$
  • (b)$T_\oplus \approx 3.6\,\text{K}$

Full worked solutions: BAAO Astro Challenge: Complete Solutions (book)

2019 Q122019Section B · Short answerGalaxies and Cosmology · Hubble's law and the age of the Universe
Age of the Universe

A consequence of the expansion of the Universe is that galaxies appear to be moving away from us, and the further they are away the quicker they seem to be moving. Edwin Hubble showed that if the expansion was uniform in all directions then the relationship can be expressed as $v = H_0 d$ where $v$ is the recessional velocity, $d$ is the distance to the galaxy, and $H_0$ is called the Hubble constant. His original compilation of this data from his 1929 paper is shown in Figure 2.

figure
Figure 2: The original plot of recessional velocity (based upon redshifts) given in $\mathrm{km~s^{-1}}$ (despite the incorrect axes labels) and distances given in $\mathrm{Mpc}$ ($=10^6\,\mathrm{pc}$) to 32 nearby galaxies. The solid line shows the best fit to the individual data points. Credit: Hubble (1929).

Whilst the measured redshifts used to derive the values of $v$ are largely consistent with the modern values, the distances are considerably different from the ones we accept today. Even so, we can repeat the analysis he did to get a rough value for the age of the Universe, despite it being rather different from our current estimates.

(a) Making full use of the graph, calculate the value of $H_0$, giving your answer in units of $\mathrm{km~s^{-1}~Mpc^{-1}}$.

(b) The age of the Universe, $t$, is related to $H_0$ by $t = k H_0^n$ where $k$ is a unitless numerical factor. By considering the dimensions of $H_0$ in SI units, find a value for $n$ and, given $k = 1$, calculate $t$ from your value of $H_0$. Give your answer in $\mathrm{Gyr}$ ($= 10^9$ years).

Show answer · 显示答案
Final answers · 最终答案
  • (a)$H_0 \approx 510 \pm 10 \text{ km s}^{-1} \text{ Mpc}^{-1}$
  • (b)$t \approx 1.92 \text{ Gyr}$

Full worked solutions: BAAO Astro Challenge: Complete Solutions (book)

2020 Q32020Section A · Multiple choiceGalaxies and Cosmology · Dark matter and galaxy rotation curves

A very strong argument for the existence of dark matter is:
A. The existence of a supermassive black hole at the centre of most large galaxies
B. The shape of the rotation curve of spiral galaxies
C. The detection of neutrino emission from Type II supernovae
D. That almost all galactic spectra are redshifted

Show answer · 显示答案
Answer · 答案
B

Full worked solutions: BAAO Astro Challenge: Complete Solutions (book)

2020 Q132020Section C · Long answerGalaxies and Cosmology · Radiation, matter and dark-energy epochs
History of the Universe

The Universe consists of radiation, matter, and dark energy, with three different epochs in its history.

The Universe consists of three main components: radiation (including neutrinos), matter (both atoms and dark matter), and dark energy. The overall density of the universe has been dominated by the density of each of those in turn at different times in its history, leading to three different epochs.

figure

The scale factor, $a$, describes how the Universe has expanded (i.e. a measure of the relative radius of the Universe), and the current value is defined as $a_0 \equiv 1$ where the subscript ' 0 ' indicates it is as measured today. At earlier times $a<1$ and at the Big Bang $a=0$.

The redshift of an object, $z$, is related to the scale factor as $a=(1+z)^{-1}$ and so the redshift corresponding to now is $z=0$, and far away objects have higher redshift $(z>0)$ since we observe them as they were long ago when the scale factor was smaller.

For a Universe to be flat (i.e. zero curvature), its average density must be equal to the critical density,

$$ \rho_{\text {crit }, 0}=\frac{3 H_0^2}{8 \pi G}, $$

where $H_0$ is the Hubble constant, measured in 2018 from the cosmic microwave background by the Planck spacecraft to be $67.36 \mathrm{~km} \mathrm{~s}^{-1} \mathrm{Mpc}^{-1}$.

The density of the $i^{\text {th }}$ component of the Universe can be expressed relative to the critical density as the density parameter,

$$ \Omega_i=\frac{\rho_i}{\rho_{\text {crit }}} $$

Planck measured the current density parameters of dark energy and matter as $\Omega_{\Lambda, 0}=0.6847$ and $\Omega_{m, 0}=0.3153$ respectively.

In each epoch, the scale factor increases at a different rate with time, $t$, as the density also varies differently with scale factor.

- Radiation-dominated epoch: The Universe's early history, where $\rho \propto a^{-4}$ and so $a \propto t^{1 / 2}$

- Matter-dominated epoch: This represents much of the history of the Universe, where $\rho \propto a^{-3}$ and so $a \propto t^{2 / 3}$

- Dark-energy-dominated epoch: This is an era we have recently entered and will remain in for the rest of time, where $\rho$ doesn't vary with scale factor (i.e. is a constant) and so $a \propto e^{H_0 t}$

(a) Assuming our Universe is flat, calculate the current average density of the Universe.

(b) Find the time, $t_{D E}$, when the current epoch began (i.e. when the densities of dark energy and matter were equal), given that the age of the Universe today is $t_0=13.80 \mathrm{Gyr}$ (where 1 Gyr $=10^9$ years). Give you answer in Gyr. You do not need to read anything off the graph.

(c) Assuming the Universe has always been flat, find the time $t_{\text {eq }}$, corresponding to when the densities of matter and radiation were equal, given that data from Planck has allowed us to calculate the redshift of this to be $z_{e q}=3402$, and find the average density of the Universe at $t_{e q}$. Again, do not try and read any data off the graph.

Show answer · 显示答案
Final answers · 最终答案
  • (a)$\rho_{\mathrm{crit},0} \approx 8.53\times10^{-27}\ \text{kg m}^{-3}$
  • (b)$t_{DE} \approx 10.0\ \text{Gyr}$
  • (c)$\rho_{eq} \approx 2.1\times10^{-16}\ \text{kg m}^{-3}$

Full worked solutions: BAAO Astro Challenge: Complete Solutions (book)

2022 Q122022Section B · Short answerGalaxies and Cosmology · Distance to an ancient galaxy: redshift and lensing
Distance to an Ancient Galaxy

The very first image released by the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) was of a galaxy cluster called SMACS 0723. The image is considered to be Webb's first deep field, since a long exposure time of 12.5 hours was used to allow the light from very faint and distant galaxies to be seen. The spectrum of one such galaxy is shown in Figure 2.

figure
figure
Figure 2: Highly redshifted emission lines in the spectrum of a galaxy that is 13.1 billion years old, captured using the JWST's near-infrared spectrometer (NIRSpec).

The spectrum shows four bright hydrogen lines, which are part of the Balmer series (some of which are normally seen in the visible). The rest frame wavelengths of the longest four lines in the series are $410$ nm, $434$ nm, $486$ nm and $656$ nm (not all of which are visible in the spectrum).

Once a redshift is known, its recessional velocity can be calculated. At very high redshifts, such as these, General Relativity must be used. A conversion from redshift to recessional velocity is shown in Figure 3.

(a) Taking measurements from the spectrum, estimate the redshift of the galaxy. [Hint: you should measure more than one line to ensure you correctly identify which rest frame wavelength corresponds to which line.]

(b) Taking the value of the Hubble constant to be $H_0 = 70$ km s$^{-1}$ Mpc$^{-1}$, what is the distance to the galaxy? Give your answer in Mpc.

Show answer · 显示答案
Final answers · 最终答案
  • (a)$\bar{z} \approx 8.5$
  • (b)$d\approx9.1\times10^3\,\mathrm{Mpc}\quad\text{(digitised graph)}$ Corrected — the printed ≈10,000 Mpc uses v≈2.3c; digitising Fig. 3 gives v≈2.12c (reasonable graph-reading estimates remain acceptable); see the interactive walkthrough.

Full worked solutions: BAAO Astro Challenge: Complete Solutions (book)

2023 Q82023Section A · Multiple choiceGalaxies and Cosmology · The nearest large galaxy

Which of these constellations contains the nearest (comparable size) galaxy to the Milky Way?

A.B.C.D.
figurefigurefigurefigure
Show answer · 显示答案
Answer · 答案
D

Full worked solutions: BAAO Astro Challenge: Complete Solutions (book)

2023 Q132023Section C · Long answerGalaxies and Cosmology · Age of the high-redshift galaxy GN-z11
Age of a Young Galaxy

The high-redshift galaxy GN-z11 was discovered in images from the Hubble Space Telescope (HST) in 2015 and announced in Oesch et al.\ (2016) as having a redshift of $z = 11.09$, making it the most distant galaxy known at the time and only overtaken recently by those discovered by the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST). Due to its extreme distance it was close to the limit of HST detectability and so it was very hard to get a good spectrum, however the superior optics of JWST has allowed Bunker et al.\ (2023) to get a very detailed spectrum with excellent signal-to-noise allowing a considerable number of properties of the galaxy to be measured for the first time, including a precise redshift of $z = 10.6034$, which corresponds to a luminosity distance of $d_L = 113150$ Mpc in their chosen cosmology. This spectrum is shown below.

figure

One of the advantages of a detailed spectrum is to try and determine the properties of the ultraviolet (UV) continuum (that is, the underlying shape of the spectrum, ignoring absorption and emission lines) which can be used to work out the star formation rate (SFR) and hence get an estimate for the age of the galaxy, since UV photons are mostly emitted by large, hot stars that have short lives so indicative of recent bursts of star formation.

(a) Astronomers are normally interested in the continuum UV flux at around 150 nm in the emitted (rest) frame to work out the SFR. By considering the shape of the continuum from rest frame 140 to 160 nm, measure the spectral flux density from the graph at $\lambda_{\mathrm{emit}} = 150$ nm, and hence show that the absolute magnitude of this galaxy at that wavelength is $-22 < \mathcal{M} < -21$.

(b) Given the Sun has an absolute magnitude of 4.74 and assuming that all of the photons being emitted are monochromatic with $\lambda_{\mathrm{emit}} = 150$ nm, determine the SFR of the galaxy. (Use $\mathcal{M} = -21$ if you were unable to get a value in the previous part.)

(c) The mass of the galaxy is $\sim 10^9 M_{\odot}$. Assuming a constant SFR, estimate an age for the galaxy. Given the Universe is 430 million years old at this redshift, is this age possible?

Helpful formulae: At high redshifts, the relationship between apparent and absolute magnitudes is modified to $$m - \mathcal{M} = 5\log\!\left(\frac{d_L}{10}\right) - 2.5\log(1+z),$$ where $d_L$ is the luminosity distance in pc determined by the value of cosmological parameters used.

The apparent magnitude is related to the spectral flux density, $F_\nu$, in units of jansky (Jy) as $$m = -2.5\log\!\left(\frac{F_\nu}{3631}\right).$$

Spectral flux densities in erg s$^{-1}$ cm$^{-2}$ Å$^{-1}$ can be converted into Jy using $$F_\nu = 3.34 \times 10^{6}\,\lambda^2\,F_\lambda,$$ where $\lambda$ is the observed wavelength in nm.

Kennicutt (1998) showed that the SFR, in units of $M_\odot$ year$^{-1}$, can be calculated as $$\mathrm{SFR} = 1.08 \times 10^{-53}\,N_{\mathrm{ion}},$$ where $N_{\mathrm{ion}}$ is the number of ionising photons emitted per second by the galaxy.

Show answer · 显示答案
Final answers · 最终答案
  • (a)$\mathcal{M} \approx -21.2$
  • (b)$\mathrm{SFR} \approx 60\,M_{\odot}\,\mathrm{yr^{-1}}$
  • (c)$t_{\mathrm{age}} \approx 16\,\mathrm{Myr}$

Full worked solutions: BAAO Astro Challenge: Complete Solutions (book)

2024 Q32024Section A · Multiple choiceGalaxies and Cosmology · Recessional acceleration from Hubble's law

Using Hubble's law for recessional velocities of distant objects, find a possible expression to estimate the recessional acceleration, $a$, of an object as a function of distance, $d$, and the Hubble constant, $H_0$.
A. $a = H_0^2 d$
B. $a = H_0 d^2$
C. $a = (H_0 d)^2$
D. $a = H_0 d$

Show answer · 显示答案
Answer · 答案
A

Full worked solutions: BAAO Astro Challenge: Complete Solutions (book)

2024 Q52024Section A · Multiple choiceGalaxies and Cosmology · The Euclid survey

The Euclid space mission, launched in 2023, will image $36\%$ of the sky in extremely high resolution to investigate the nature of dark energy and dark matter by looking at the shapes of huge numbers of distant galaxies. The visible instrument (VIS) consists of a $6 \times 6$ matrix of $4096 \times 4132$ pixel CCDs. If the scale of the image on the CCD is $0.101''$ pixel$^{-1}$ in each axis, estimate the minimum number of photos the instrument needs to take to get the planned coverage (ignoring any gaps between the CCDs)?
A. 31000
B. 49000
C. 86000
D. 135000

Show answer · 显示答案
Answer · 答案
A

Full worked solutions: BAAO Astro Challenge: Complete Solutions (book)